The Headmaster's New Clothes
Rethinking School Leadership in the 21st Century
Whenever a head of a school is portrayed in children’s literature they loom large and menacing. From the terrifying Miss Trunchbull in Roald Dahl's Matilda, to the sinister Demon Headmaster in Gillian Cross' Eponymous series, these characters are known for their strictness, harshness, and - at times - outright cruelty. They are figures of authority and discipline, often feared rather than respected by their students.
The role of the headteacher or principal has long been associated with a similar sense of authority and discipline. They were the ones you were sent to for punishment, the ones who ruled their staff with an iron rod, and the ones you avoided outside their office.
However, the traditional model of the stern, distant headteacher is thankfully undergoing a significant transformation.
The Changing Face of School Leadership
Today, the duties of the headteacher remain broadly the same.
They are responsible for the overall management of the school, the implementation of the curriculum, the maintenance of discipline, and the welfare of the students.
However, the manner in which these duties are carried out is changing and, while we whisper it gently, the days of the ‘angry head’ may finally be over.
The Headteacher as a Facilitator
In the new model of school leadership, the headteacher is less of a dictator, and more of a facilitator. They are no longer the sole authority figure, but rather a member of a team of leaders, each with their own areas of expertise and responsibility.
This shift is not just about changing the job description of the headteacher; it's about changing the culture of our schools.
In this new culture, teachers are empowered to take on leadership roles within their schools. They are given the autonomy to make decisions about their classrooms and their students, and are supported in their efforts to improve their teaching practices. They are encouraged to collaborate with their colleagues, to share their expertise, and to learn from each other.
They are valued not just for their ability to teach, but for their ability to lead.
And the headteacher's role in this new culture is to facilitate this process.
They are there to provide support and guidance, to create an environment where teachers feel safe to take risks and try new things, and to ensure that the school's resources are used effectively to support teaching and learning. They are there to listen to their staff, to value their ideas and contributions, and to encourage them to take on leadership roles.
This is a far cry from the old model of the headmaster, but it is a very necessary change.
Our schools are complex, dynamic environments, and they need leaders who can navigate these intricacies. They need leaders who can inspire and empower their staff, who can foster a culture of collaboration and continuous improvement, and who can put the needs of their students at the heart of every single choice they make.
The old model of the headmaster may be dead, but the new model of the headteacher is alive and well. It's a model that recognizes the importance of collaboration, empowerment, and continuous learning.
It is a model that is far better suited to the challenges and opportunities of the 21st century.
Yet the transformation of school leadership is not without its challenges. According to a report by the GOV.UK Ethnicity Facts and Figures, 92.5% of headteachers were white British, while 75.7% of teachers were women. The proportion of men in school leadership and management positions is higher than within the general teaching force globally. These statistics highlight the need for greater diversity in school leadership.
The Rise of Teacher Leadership
In some schools, the role of the principal or headteacher is being reimagined, or even eliminated altogether. Instead, these schools are embracing the concept of teacher leadership, a process where teachers influence and improve teaching and learning practices within and beyond their classrooms for the benefit of all students.
Teacher leaders are not just effective educators; they are also change agents, communicators, and collaborators.
They introduce new initiatives, collaborate with other school members, and perform various leadership functions. They are still deeply connected to the classroom and to their students, but they also step outside these doors to lead change in their schools.
Teacher leaders exemplify certain defining characteristics.
They are experts in their fields, exceptional communicators, change agents, inspirational leaders, trustworthy colleagues, and explorers. They share their expertise, listen to and understand different perspectives, initiate and support evolution, build trust through honesty and reliability, and are willing to explore new ideas and initiatives.
Perhaps most importantly, they inspire others to be their best.
Real-world examples of teacher leadership abound, demonstrating the transformative power of this approach. The ASCD outlines ten roles for teacher leaders, including resource provider, instructional specialist, curriculum specialist, classroom supporter, learning facilitator, mentor, school leader, data coach, catalyst for change, and learner. These roles highlight the diverse ways in which teachers can contribute to their schools' success, shaping the culture of their institutions, improving student learning, and influencing practice among their peers.
For instance, at Samuel Mason Elementary School, shared leadership transformed student achievement. When the school developed leadership teams made up of teachers and administrators to make schoolwide decisions, they noticed rising test scores in reading and mathematics. This example illustrates how shared leadership can directly impact student outcomes.
Moreover, shared leadership has been shown to improve teacher retention. According to Learning Forward, when teachers are given leadership opportunities, schools are better able to retain teachers for the long term. Teacher leaders become more engaged in their work as they feel greater responsibility for the success of their students and school.
Finally, shared leadership can help close equity gaps. The Stanford Center for Opportunity Policy in Education (SCOPE) found that shared leadership supports equitable student-centred learning. Teachers have a greater capacity to personalise instruction based on students’ individual needs when they have adequate support, especially through shared leadership and professional development.
The rise of teacher leadership is not just a trend, but a paradigm shift in how we view educational leadership.
It challenges the traditional model of the headmaster and offers a more collaborative, inclusive, and effective approach to leading schools. The old model of the headmaster may not be dead, but it is certainly evolving, and teacher leadership is at the forefront of this evolution.
The Future of School Leadership
The shift towards teacher leadership suggests a future where school leadership is more collaborative and less hierarchical. It suggests a future where teachers are not just implementers of decisions made by a distant authority figure, but active participants in the decision-making process. It suggests a future where the role of the headteacher is not to rule with an iron rod, but to guide, support, and empower their staff.
This is not to say that the role of the headteacher will become obsolete.
Rather, it will evolve to meet the changing needs of our schools and our students. The headteacher of the future may be less of a stern disciplinarian, and more of a supportive coach, less of a distant figure and more of a collaborative leader.
The old model of the headmaster may indeed be increasingly dead, but in its place is emerging a new and exciting model of school leadership that is more inclusive, more collaborative, and more responsive to the needs of our students.
It is a change that is long overdue, and will undoubtedly be in the best interests of our students, teachers, and schools alike.
References